In Amy Clipston's first Amish YA novel tied to the Kauffman Amish Bakery series, Lydia Bontrager seems to have the perfect Amish life until her youngest sister is diagnosed with cancer. With the added pressures at home, her community's displeasure at Lydia befriending an English boy, and a splintering relationship with the only boy she's ever loved, Lydia feels as if she's losing everything she's ever held true.